Do Onions Kill Rats?

Last Updated:

Tired and mentally exhausted homeowners, dealing with pesky rats, are probably tempted to try unconventional methods like onions to get rid of them. Rather than spray the home with pesticides or toxicants, you probably want a “natural” solution that offers the same degree of efficacy as commercial pest control. 

Natural solutions are plentiful online – everything from essential oils to salt to onions are recommended as rat repellent. Some work and some don’t.

Unfortunately with onions, the answer might not be what you want to hear. Don’t be so certain that this culinary staple will do the trick for a full-blown infestation, as it may not be as effective or safe as you might think.

We’ll explore whether onions can actually kill rats, the dangers of using them for rat control in a home environment, and suggest alternative proven methods to help keep these unwelcome guests out.

Key Takeaways

Onions are not effective at killing rats. Onions are toxic to rats in high doses, but rats simply won’t eat enough to consume a lethal amount.
Onions are toxic to cats and dogs making them unsuitable for use in a home with pets.
Rather than onions, use natural rat repellents like peppermint oil, cayenne pepper, or bay leaves.
If natural remedies are ineffective, try rat traps or rat poison.
If DIY methods fail, call a local pest control company to handle your rat problem.

Natural Rat Killers – Onions Might Work

There is no scientific evidence to support the idea that onions can effectively kill rats, despite being toxic to rodents. Rats have a strong sense of smell that allows them to easily detect onions, ensuring they don’t consume them due to the natural presence of disulfides. However, if a large enough quantity of raw onion is consumed, it may effectively kill rodents. 

Concrete Evidence

When it comes to the popular myth of using onions as a rat-killing method, there is a significant lack of scientific evidence that supports this claim. 

Many blogs and websites claim that onions can effectively kill rats. 

This is entirely based on the fact that raw onions contain compounds called thiosulfate and allyl propyl disulfide. These compounds are present in onions, green onions, shallots, and garlic – and are poisonous to dogs and cats as well. 

Thiosulfate and other disulfides cause a condition known as “hemolytic anemia,” which is a physical manifestation of damage to red blood cells. This can be fatal. The bodies of these animals are unable to effectively break down the thiosulfate and related compounds. 

Symptoms in pets include vomiting, lethargy, rapid breathing, and an elevated heart rate.

However, there is no determining how effective raw onions will be in clearing a rodent infestation from your home – given the amount each rat would have to consume. Most claims online are anecdotal, and not backed up by actual evidence. This process also isn’t instantaneous, and it can take days for the thiosulfate to impact the blood cells within the rats. 

This absence of proof doesn’t mean that onions  have no effect on rats – or can’t kill them. We do know that the sulfur compounds in onions and garlic are, in fact, toxic to rodents. We just can’t ascertain how effective they are.

There are no reputable studies or research conducted on this specific topic to back up online claims. Provided you don’t have pets of your own, it certainly wouldn’t hurt to try. Just ensure they are raw onions, and not cooked. 

In fact, cooked onions pose no threat to rodents at all, since the high temperatures involved neutralize any potentially harmful sulfur compounds.

Onions on a Cutting Board

Rats Can Easily Detect Onions

Contrary to popular belief, onions are generally not toxic enough to kill rats in consumed quantities. This misconception may have arisen due to the presence of thiosulfate and disulfides in onions – compounds that can be harmful (fatal) when ingested by some animals, including dogs and cats.

However, even if a rat were to eat a large amount of onion, it would most likely only suffer from minor digestive disruption rather than acute poisoning. Rats have an extraordinary olfactory ability which allows them to detect potentially harmful substances in their food sources effortlessly – another reason they wouldn’t fall victim to a stray raw onion easily. 

Most rats will avoid onions, unless otherwise disguised by more appealing food sources. 

Rats possess a highly developed sense of smell, which enables them to detect odors from great distances and avoid potential threats in their environment. This keen olfactory ability is particularly disadvantageous for individuals attempting to use onions as rat killers.

In fact, the strong smell of onions could cause rodents to flee an area rather than consume the onion itself. Therefore, relying on onions as a method for eliminating rats is ineffective and may inadvertently lead these pests away from localized traps or baits. Utilizing them outdoors in a garden, however, can be an effective natural repellant. 

Effective Rat Control Methods

Seal any potential entry points, eliminate sources of food and water, use traps or baits, or hire a professional exterminator for effective control of rat infestation.

Seal Entry Points

One of the most effective methods of rat control is to seal potential entry points. Rats can enter a building through small cracks and holes, so sealing these entry points is crucial to prevent infestations.

Examples of areas that should be sealed include gaps around pipes, vents, windows, doors, and utility lines. It’s recommended to use steel wool or mesh wire to block any openings as rats can chew through softer materials like wood or plastic.

Eliminate Sources of Food and Water

Rats are attracted to areas where they can easily find food and water, making it important to eliminate these sources of attraction first. One effective way is by ensuring proper sanitation techniques, such as regularly disposing of garbage in tightly sealed bins and cleaning up any spills or crumbs that may attract rats.

Use Traps or Bait

Effective rat control methods include the use of commercial traps or baits. Traps are designed to capture rats alive for release, or kill them instantly. Snap traps and glue traps are some popular options for trapping and killing rats in homes, although glue traps are much less humane. 

It is important to note that when using any trap or bait option, it is crucial to place them strategically along potential entry points or areas where rats have been spotted. Rat droppings are also a good indicator. 

Rodents can be intelligent creatures that quickly learn to avoid areas with traps or baits once their peers start getting caught.

Rat Trap on White Background

Hire Professional Exterminators

If you have a rat problem, it’s essential you contact a professional exterminator. These experts are certified and trained in rodent control practices, providing effective and safe solutions for your pest problems. They can also examine and determine key entry points for the rats, ensuring they’re sealed off – preventing breeding inside your home. 

By hiring an exterminator, you’ll receive integrated pest management services that aim to eliminate the actual root cause of the infestation, rather than merely managing symptoms. You don’t want a band-aid solution. 

While DIY methods such as bleach may seem cost-effective initially, long-term consequences can be more expensive, especially if rats continue to breed inside the walls of your home. 

Risks and Dangers of Using Onions to Kill Rats

Using onions to kill rats can pose risks and dangers, including potential harm to pets and humans, the attraction of more rats, as well as being an unnecessary and ineffective method.

Potential Harm to Pets

Using onions to kill rats can pose potential harm to pets and humans. We don’t recommend this pest control DIY method if you have any dogs or cats as pets. Onions contain the aforementioned sulfur compounds, which are extremely toxic to cats and dogs if ingested.

Some signs of toxicity in pets include vomiting, diarrhea, abdominal pain, weakness, and pale gums – more concerning warning signs include a rapid heartbeat and labored breathing. 

Onions might prove fatal to rodents, but it’s a slow death. And that’s if they end up consuming them. Onions are not part of a rat’s regular diet and continually exposing them to it can lead to impaired red blood cells – but only over time (around 48 hours).

It’s always best to consult professionals in pest control for an effective solution tailored towards animal welfare while managing rodent infestations safely, without resorting to harmful substances or toxic homemade solutions.

Natural Rat Repellents

In addition to onions, there are other natural rat repellents that can be used for rodent control or repellent, such as peppermint oil, cayenne pepper, and bay leaves. These shouldn’t be considered as effective options for killing rats, but can help to deter them. 

Peppermint Oil

Peppermint oil is an effective natural rat repellent due to its strong and pungent scent, which irritates the rodent’s olfactory senses. It disrupts their ability to track food sources and communicate with other rats, ultimately driving them away from a particular area.

While peppermint oil works well for deterring rats on a small scale, it won’t be sufficient for large-scale infestations. 

Cayenne Pepper

Cayenne pepper is a powerful natural rat repellent that can help deter them from your home or garden. This spice contains capsaicin, a substance that causes skin irritation in rats and other pests, making them less likely to sneak onto your property or linger for long.

Cayenne powder can be sprinkled along known pathways, entryways, or near nesting sites. You can also add it to compost bins, bird feeders, and garden beds to deter rodents from getting too close.

Crushed Cayenne Pepper with Full Peppers on Wooden Board

Bay Leaves

Bay leaves are a natural deterrent for rats due to their potent aroma. However, it is essential to note that whole bay leaves can help repel rats, they are highly toxic and dangerous if ingested by them.

If you want to use bay leaves as part of your rat control measures, consider placing the leaves near potential entry points or areas where rats may frequent. The strong smell will keep them away without harming them – if you are looking to kill them, bay leaves are a potent natural method, since they’re more likely to be consumed than raw onion. 

Stick To Proven Rat Control Methods, or Contact Professional Pest Control Services

The idea that onions can kill rats is based in reality. Onions and garlic contain sulfur compounds, which are fatal to many animals. Unfortunately, rats have a hard-wired tendency to naturally avoid onions. You would be hard-pressed to force them to consume enough raw onion to effectively kill them – or stop an infestation. 

Instead of relying on unproven methods, stick to effective rat control strategies like sealing entry points, removing all standing sources of food and water, using commercial traps or baits, and hiring a professional exterminator. If you have an infestation throughout your home, garage, or basement – you need the help of a professional. 

Photo of author
Sean is the founder of Conquer Critters. With more than 17 years of experience in dealing with various pests, he is passionate about spreading his knowledge to help everyone manage their pest problem in the fastest, most effective manor possible.

Leave a Comment